Lomborg-errors
|
|
Analysis of gases in ice cores: The lag of the CO2 signal behind the temperature signal |
|
Gore
error list
Cool It, British
Cool It, American
|
ANALYSING AIR
BUBBLES IN ICE CORES
Snow that is deposited on the surface of an
ice sheet is gradually transformed into a mass of fine ice crystals,
called firn. As more and more snow is deposited on top, the firn below
is compressed to become ice; in the process, air bubbles are trapped in
this ice.
Air from above may still diffuse into the ice for a long time, but when
the ice has become sufficiently compressed, and ice crystals have
recrystallized to form coherent solid ice, air from above can no longer
enter, and the trapped air remains shut off from the
atmosphere. The formation of air bubbles is described here.
A crucial question is: how much younger is the
trapped air than the surrounding ice?
To answer this question, scientists have studied the
distribution of air with differing mass. The nitrogen isotope N-15 is
heavier than the normal N-14, and due to the effect of gravity, the
lowest layers of air are enriched in N-15. But when the air bubbles are
effectively shut off, this enriching is no longer possible. So when the
ice is analysed, you find a gradient in the concentration of heavy
air downwards until a certain layer where the gradient levels
off. This
layer, then, marks the transition from loose firn to solid, impermeable
ice. The age of that layer depends on the rate of snow accumulation at
the top, and is therefore different in different ice sheets. The age
difference between trapped air and the surrounding ice is typically
about 500 years in some of the important ice cores, and the uncertainty
on this age difference is probably about 20 years. Thus, in these
cases, when the age of the air bubbles is corrected relative to the age
of the surrounding ice, we end up with an uncertainty of 20 years on
the age of the air bubbles. But
where each annual layer of ice is thin, the age difference can be much
larger, and the uncertainty on the age difference can be as much as
1,000 years.
Synchronization of ice cores
If there is a sudden release of extra amounts of
some gas into the atmosphere - for instance of CH4
(methane) - then the mixing of the atmosphere will cause the change in
concentration to be equal all over the globe within about one year.
That is, if we have a characteristic set of peaks in CH4 in air from an
Antarctic ice core, and a similar set of peaks in ice cores from
Greenland, then we know that these samples are simultaneous. This makes
it possible to synchronize the time scales of Antarctic and Greenland
ice cores with great accuracy (Blunier
1998).
Measurements of temperature
Water containing oxygen-18 is heavier than water
containing oxygen-16. This has the effect that the amount of this water
that air can contain at a given temperature is low relative to the
amount of ordinary water. When moist air is blown across an ice sheet,
most of the heavier water has already condensed as precipitation, and
that which falls as precipitation (snow) on the ice, is depleted in
oxygen-18. The colder the air temperature when the water condenses, the
greater is this effect. Therefore, variations in the
oxygen-18 content of ice is a measure of the air temperature when the
ice formed, although there are some sources of errors which may modify
the signal.
The content of oxygen-18 in the O2 of
the air does also vary with global temperature, but this is a more
indirect effect (mainly due to differential consumption of heavier and
lighter oxygen in the respiration of living organisms). Most of the
precise "thermometers" of ancient temperatures are based on oxygen-18
in the ice, not in the air bubbles.
Where very exact timing is crucial, it has also been
possible to detect air temperature changes by measurements directly on
the trapped air bubbles, studying the degree of spatial separation of
air molecules with isotopes of different weight (nitrogen and argon
isotopes) (Severinghaus
et al. 1998). Thereby it is possible to relate changes
in CO2 and CH4 directly to changes in temperature in the same air
samples, especially because CH4 and N2
diffuse at the same rate into the ice.
Measurements of carbon dioxide
The concentration of carbon dioxide is measured
directly in the air that is sampled from the air bubbles in the ice.
This works well for Antarctic ice cores, but ice cores from Greenland
contain much dust with impurities that may produce carbon dioxide after
it is deposited; therefore, CO2 measurements in ice from Greenland show
certain spurious results, and thus they are considered not very
reliable.
Correlation between temperature, methane and
carbon dioxide
Recently analysed ice cores from Antarctica yield a
long time series - going back 650,000 years - with data on temperature,
CH4 and CO2. The variation over time of
these parameters were shown for instance in Al Gore´s movie, An
Inconvenient Truth, and are also depicted in the British version of
Lomborg´s book "Cool it!". The curves show an extraordinarily
close correlation between variations in all three parameters. Every
time temperature goes up, CH4 and CO2 go
up as well. However, upon very close inspection it is seen that the
temperature signal is ahead of the other two signals by a time
difference which is typically about 1,000 years. The most exact
estimate is a lag of 800 years ± 200 years (Caillon
et al., 2003). The fact that the CO2 signal lags
behind the temperature signal is interpreted by climate change skeptics
to say that temperature drives CO2, not the other way
around. This conclusion is, however, so simplified that it is wrong.
What is forgotten is that this phenomenon is seen
only in ice cores from Antarctica, not in ice cores from Greenland.
When the results for the last 50,000 years are synchronized between
Greenland and Antarctica, it turns out that each warming event
typically starts slowly in Antarctica, and then leads to at more sudden
warming in Greenland 1,000 - 2,500 years later (Blunier
1998). This means that when the warming trend finally reaches
Greenland, CO2 concentrations are already rising. In
other words, in the Northern Hemisphere the CO2 signal
does not lag behind the temperature signal. This was even more clear
when the last glaciation terminated. The temperature rise on Antarctica
started 20,000 -19,000 BP (Blunier
1998). CO2 concentrations in the Greenland ice (and
in Antarctica) started to rise about 18,000 BP (Anklin et al., J.
geophys. res. 102 (C12): 26,539-26,545). The temperature rise on the
Northern Hemisphere started very abruptly at the end of the oldest
Dryas at about 14,700 years ago, and the temperature rise in the
tropics seems to have happened 20-30 years later than in the north (Severinghaus
& Brook 1999). Thus, CO2 had been on the rise
for about 3,300 years before the warming reached the Northern
Hemisphere and the tropics. A very similar time course happened at the
termination of another ice age about 245,000 years ago, when CO2 had
been on the rise for about 4,200 years before the warming reached the
Northern Hemisphere (Caillon
et al., 2003).
The influence of changes in the Earth´s
orbit
It is generally believed that the starting
and
ending of ice ages is triggered by cyclical changes in the
Earth´s orbit. However, these changes contribute to climate
changes with a forcing which is calculated to be only around 0.7
watt/m² (link).
This is too little to cause the full temperature jump
(4-5° C) which separates interglacial periods from glacials, but it
is enough to initiate a chain reaction as explained here:
The warming at the start of an interglacial is caused by orbital
changes which gives slightly more insolation to the seas of the
southern hemisphere. This means some warming at Antarctica - which is
recorded in the ice cores - and warming of the large masses of sea
water on the southern hemisphere. Somehow this warming leads to a rise
in atmospheric CO2, partially because when the water gets warmer, some
of the CO2 is released into the atmosphere.This CO2,
in turn, augments the
greenhouse effect and amplifies the temperature rise that is already
underway. It has been calculated that out of the total temperature rise
at the end of an ice age, between 40 and 65 % is explained by changes
in greenhouse gases (CO2 and CH4) (link).Without
changes in greenhouse gases,
the full switch from glacial to interglacial would not be possible.
The transfer of warming from the southern to the northern hemisphere.
The time lag between the temperature rise in the
Antarctic, and the rise in atmospheric CO2 is, as
stated, about 800 years. This is approximately the same time that it
takes for the oceans to exchange surface water and deep sea water. It
is therefore believed that a chain of events take place once the deep
sea water has become warmer, with concomitant changes in ocean currents
(Raynaud
et al. 2000). Because the "great ocean conveyor" transports deep
see water across the equator, heat will be transferred to the Northern
Hemisphere, once it has reached the deep sea. The northward movement of
deep sea water may have happened primarily in the Pacific Ocean, like
it is today. This has then secondarily affected
the thermohaline circulation in the North Atlantic, which pulls warmer
water from the tropics towards northern latitudes. The heat energy
necessary for this circulation has probably not been available during
the glacial period, but once heat is transferred across the equator,
and once CO2 in the atmosphere has started to rise, the
circulation could start. Once it started, heat was led towards
Greenland, which warmed. The melting of ice on the Northern Hemisphere
decreased the albedo and led to further acceleration of the warming
there. Simultaneously with this chain of events, there was a slight
cooling in the southern Hemisphere, which further corroborates that
natural temperature changes at the two poles are not precisely in
phase.
What happens now, however, is different from
anything that happened in the past: atmospheric CO2 is
increased ahead of natural warming processes, and CO2
drives the temperature rise simultaneously all over the globe.